Showing posts with label The Independent. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Independent. Show all posts

Wednesday, 29 June 2011

Johann Hari and the misleading quotes

Well Johann Hari is in a bit of trouble at the moment and I can't be the only one who's a little confused as to why it's created as much fuss as it has. From what I can tell and from what some journalists have been quick to say is that Hari has lifted quotes from other peoples interviews with his own subjects and in some cases books. The excuse Hari has given is as follows in a quote he didn't say to me, but wrote on his blog.

"When I’ve interviewed a writer, it’s quite common that they will express an idea or sentiment to me that they have expressed before in their writing – and, almost always, they’ve said it more clearly in writing than in speech. (I know I write much more clearly than I speak – whenever I read a transcript of what I’ve said, or it always seems less clear and more clotted. I think we’ve all had that sensation in one form or another).

"So occasionally, at the point in the interview where the subject has expressed an idea, I’ve quoted the idea as they expressed it in writing, rather than how they expressed it in speech."

All seems fair enough I guess, it's not straightforward plagiarism at least but the main gripe many have with Hari's excuse is that whilst this would be bad form for Hari but not unforgivable, he has on some occasions passed off a quote that his subject said in another interview as something said to him at the time. With a delicious irony I am now going to copy and paste one such example straight from the Telegraph Blog of Toby Young (which can be viewed here).

'Take this passage from his interview with [Tony] Negri:

Negri recently described the Soviet Union as “a society criss-crossed with extremely strong instances of creativity and freedom”, which is more than he has ever said for any democracy. He even says that the Soviet Union fell because it was too successful. I point this out, and he replies: “Now you are talking about memory. Who controls memory? Faced with the weight of memory, one must be unreasonable! Reason amounts to eternal Cartesianism. The most beautiful thing is to think ‘against’, to think ‘new’. Memory prevents revolt, rejection, invention, revolution.”

Compare this to what Negri said to [Anne] Dufourmentelle:

Who controls memory? Faced with the weight of memory, one must be unreasonable! Reason amounts to eternal Cartesianism.

It’s the use of a phrase like “I point this out, and he replies” that marks Hari out as a special case. That appears to stray beyond the merely misleading.'

If you know your history it's not the first time Hari has been accused of such misdeeds. You need only to go back to an article in a 2003 issue of Private Eye to find such accusations (archived here).

On Twitter the story exploded with millions of people taking up the hashtag #interviewsbyhari with the most humorous being an example I found on the Al Jazeera blog (read it here) where Twitter user @mattwithers tweeted about an imagined encounter between Hari and ex-England international, John Barnes, it reads "Barnes articulated his footballing philosophy. 'You've got to hold and give,' he said, 'but do it at the right time'. #interviewsbyhari." The line of course coming from the infamous rap in England's 1990 World Cup song World In Motion by New Order (if you don't know it, give it a listen here).

Give the man his due though, he has responded in a thoroughly honest way and it would be wrong of me not to include his views, readable on his blog here.

Articles are being written and updated on the subject almost continuously at the moment so if you want the latest on the subject your best bet is to follow any hashtags on Twitter for articles from a whole range of different perspectives and keep an eye on Hari's blog.

Until Next Time. Stay Classy Internet.

Saturday, 11 December 2010

The Independent - Journalism Now

The Independent was launched in 1986 and is one of the youngest national daily newspapers in the UK. It was first published on 7 October 1986 as a broadsheet by Newspaper Publishing plc and was created by three former journalists of The Daily Telegraph, Andreas Whittam Smith, Stephen Glover and Matthew Symonds.

Its main focus was to challenge The Guardian for centre left readers and The Times as a newspaper of record. It launched with the slogan “It is. Are you?” attracting staff from Murdoch owned broadsheets who preferred not to move to Wapping. It sparked a price war and caused a shake up with its new design style[1].

Today it is struggling to survive in the economic climate and a difficult time in general for newspapers with its ownership having changed hands to a company controlled by Alexander Lebedev and Evgeny Lebedev, the father and son team having previously bought a controlling stake in London’s Evening Standard[1].

The paper’s political stance was intended to reflect the centre of the British political spectrum but is now thought to be tending towards left wing ideals making it The Guardian’s main competitor. On the eve of the most recent general election however it made its stance clear, advising “There is a strong case for progressively minded voters to lend their support to the Liberal Democrats.”[1]

On The Independent website it claims its readers are mostly male with 57%, this is also the same percentage whom the paper believes are solus readers; people who only read The Independent[2]. It places its readers in the ABC1 category which is not surprising considering the news agenda and even the price of the paper. When compared to the Daily Star at about 30p, £1 actually seems like quite a lot to pay for a newspaper.

The audience can also be discerned from the advertising with large adverts for brands such as House of Fraser or Waitrose, the paper is placing itself firmly in the ABC1 bracket. A page advert in colour in The Independent in a specified position is £16,660[3] so companies like Currys must think it worthwhile to advertise in the paper even with its small readership.

The audience profiles also suggest that most of their readers are professionals as 59% are in full time employment with 50% with degree level or higher in their education. A large majority as well are from the London and South East area[2].

The newspaper’s agenda ranges from political prisoners to climate change and often focuses on the stories like this that it sees as more ‘worthy’. You will not find celebrity based gossip in The Independent although you are more likely to find it on the website.

The Independent has also recently launched the ‘I’ newspaper which runs in conjunction with The Independent as its cheaper and more disposable cousin. The editorial is mostly similar and in fact on some days the articles that appear in The Independent find their way into the ‘I’; it just strikes me as odd however that a paper that is struggling to stay afloat has introduced yet another rival, one that is cheaper and more cost effective.

Like all newspapers and especially the ‘qualities’, The Independent’s circulation is dropping rapidly with 183,547 copies in circulation daily. This is down by 10.88% on the previous year. With this in mind it is difficult to see whether the newspaper can survive in the current economic climate or will the populist tabloids soon be the only papers we have.


Sources:
[1] Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Independent
[2] The Independent Website http://www.independentonlinesolutions.com/advertisingGuide/media/indy.pdf
[3] The Independent Website http://www.independentonlinesolutions.com/advertisingGuide/cards.html

Friday, 26 November 2010

Journalism Now Project - The Independent and BBC Radio 2

The Independent and BBC Radio 2 seem to have nothing in common but the audiences of the two media institutions appear, on inspection, to be fairly similar. Although Radio 2 has no rate cards for public viewing, the general consensus is that Radio 2 is the middle of the road alternative to Radio 1. A sort of breeding ground for people who are yet to make the leap (metaphorically speaking) to Radio 4.

The Independent, nicknamed ‘The Indy’, was launched in 1986 and is one of the youngest daily newspapers in the UK. It changed to tabloid format in 2003 retaining broadsheet sensibilities and, despite its lack of affiliation to any particular political party; it is generally thought to lean to the left. It struggles financially though and this affects its news agenda as it cannot afford journalists to go out and collect stories through investigative journalism. This means many of the stories the newspaper contains are analysis or comment pieces as they cannot afford court journalists and stories. Originally it provided a challenge to Murdoch, producing spoofs of The Times and The Telegraph within its pages but once The Times began to reduce prices, the ‘Indy’s’ circulation began to suffer. The Independent’s news agenda tends towards political prisoners, climate change or campaigning. The celebrity based tabloid news does not even get a look in as The Independent places itself in the more serious quarter of newspapers, avoiding the reality TV shows and focusing instead on what it considers more worthy issues.

BBC Radio 2 has become an institution and has recently been named ‘the nation’s favourite’ as it is currently the most listened to radio station in the UK. Although the station has no rate cards which the public can access, it is still possible to get some audience figures. The information I found suggested it has a reach of 13,682,000 out of a possible survey area of 51,618,000[1]. It focuses mainly on the big stories of the day as these do not require comment that the BBC is unable to give as an impartial channel. The news on 19th November followed for most of the day the bailing out of Ireland or the refusal of Ireland to be bailed out by the EU’s monetary fund. It covered other major stories such as the increase in public borrowing and the suspension of two FIFA executives who tried to sell their World Cup bid vote. However, the stories at the end of the bulletins were of most interest to me. At 10am we had a man arrested after stealing a poppy collection box, which was a serious news story, but by 5pm we had the “And finally” story with a court in Germany banning a man from tattooing a horse with the Rolling Stones logo.

To compare the two media institutions is, as I have discovered, quite difficult. This is partly because they are targeted towards their audiences differently. Despite their differences, their commitment to news is unwavering and their dedication to the art of journalism unstoppable.


Footnotes:
[1] BBC Radio 2 audience figures www.mediauk.com

Monday, 15 November 2010

Libel - Current Example

In The Independent today there is a column on media studies within the daily Viewspaper which talks about The Spectator having recently been on the receiving end of some expensive legal cases. The first dates back to 2008 when their site published an article by Stephen Pollard, editor of the Jewish Chronicle, which described a London based Islamist group called IslamExpo as racist, fascist and genocidal. Possibly not the best way to avoid libel action. A couple of months back the magazine had to post an apology but only after incurring substantial losses.

An influential figure of the IslamExpo group, a Palestinian emigre by the name of Mohammed Sawalha has also been settled with by The Spectator after a blog was published on their website which the man considered libellous. The blog, by Melanie Phillips has also incurred costs to the magazine, said to run into hundreds of thousands of pounds. Although these were relatively small publications, they are of course still vulnerable to all sorts of legal action. Middle Eastern politics must be negotiated with care as they present a danger to journalists who do not know their facts. This is also a good example of how dangerous it is sometimes to just put any old thing in your blog. I for one will be more careful from now on, especially as I now know the dangers and can no longer claim ignorance, for all that would have done.