Apologies to the Daily Telegraph for nicking their headline but it's a good one. So yes, as you may have heard, the News of the World phone hacking scandal rolls on taking it's biggest casualty yet as the paper is shut down. It was founded in 1843, bought by Rupert Murdoch and his News Ltd company in 1969 and is scheduled to close this Sunday the 10th of July in the wake of the phone hacking scandal.
Is the closure of the News of the World honestly addressing the problem? Already shouts have gone up from some media commentators at the cynical way in which the paper has been closed as a scapegoat for other, much more troubling issues. The first of which is Rebekah Brooks (nee Wade) still holds her job as head of News International when the majority of the hacking took place leading some to joke that Murdoch has gotten rid of the wrong red top (make the connections yourself, you're not stupid). I suppose you could be wondering what is so terrible about the hacking, after all, it was only celebrities hacked right? Sienna Miller won compensation, Andy Gray was hacked as was Hugh Grant (more on him later) and OK the odd politician like John Prescott but what's the big deal. Well I'll tell you. It wasn't just celebrities, in the last week alone we have discovered that the Private Investigators seemingly hired by the NotW hacked the then missing Milly Dowler's phone, the parents of one of the victims of the Soham murders, the families of those killed in the 7/7 bombings and families of soldiers killed on duty in Iraq and Afghanistan. Now this may seem bad enough or it may seem absolutely acceptable depending on your point of view but where they unequivocally crossed the line to me is when they deleted messages on Milly Dowler's phone to make room for more from worried family members, leading her family to believe she was still accessing her phone and therefore still alive which by this time she had sadly met her end.
The actions have been described variously as disgusting, unacceptable and all sorts of other big words which fail to actually bring about any real outcome. It seems that an enquiry will come but how soon and how independent, especially important given that there is a suggestion of corruption in the Metropolitan Police Force. The Police are currently holding their own enquiry and according to Chris Grayling, a judicial enquiry cannot run alongside it. Not knowing the law on this I cannot comment with much authority but I cannot understand why the two can not run concurrently. the suggestion by other panellists was that because the government is 'in bed with Murdoch' as the slightly sordid sounding phrase goes, they want to leave the enquiry as long as possible in the hope that we the public will somehow forget about it. And they are right. We need to act now to get to the bottom of this, this could be one of the most important times for the media, the government and even the public at large. The Press Complaints Commission (PCC) have been criticised, seen as an ineffective way of controlling the press but as their Chairman has pointed out in various interviews and press conferences, you can't regulate a company which consistently lies to you.
In yesterday's Question Time, Hugh Grant, a victim of the hacking himself, went down very well amongst the general public with his views on the NotW, Murdoch and has become a crusader against the hacking which, if nothing else has ensured his movie career will continue for years to come. One thing however was brought to my attention after the programme that, as a training journalist bothered me. Grant at one point spoke of a change in the way in which the press are regulated, something which many would agree with but the draconian measures he seemed to suggest the like of which haven't been seen since the 1800s and although he resorted in the end to cheap digs about Grant's tabloid past, Jon Gaunt was right in saying that too much regulation on the press will mean we no longer have a free press. A free press being essential in a true democracy to hold to account politicians, businessmen and the like.
Something that worried me in all the accusations and revelations was the reaction of the other newspapers to the stories. On the day after the biggest revelations that Milly Dowler's phone was hacked and messages were deleted, the reaction was less than some expected. The Daily Mail for example had a small front page article, a page inside and a small piece in the comment section of the paper. You can be sure it was the same across the board. Take what you want from this but it suggests that the hacking practice was not limited to the News of the World. To think however as some do that this makes all journalists scum is to be more foolish and naive than you could imagine. With the closure of the News of the World we lose the biggest selling newspaper in this country and around 200 staff will lose their jobs as the paper closes. Not all of these people would have been involved in the hacking, most will be PR people and journalists who were just going about their own business doing quality journalism on what used to be a quality newspaper.
As a final thought what will happen with Rupert Murdoch's take over of BSkyB. The decision will obviously be postponed but surely recent events will stop the sale which appeared to be taking place despite laws which should prevent any one person owning such a high percentage of the media. Will Rebekah Brooks ever leave? Andy Coulson has today been arrested and how long can Murdoch protect Brooks with the comprehensive investigations and inquiries ahead of us. Her ability to stay on has lead to many speculating on what it she has (from a nuclear bomb to bikini pictures of Murdoch. Obviously a twitter source). What will it mean for journalists in the future? The phone hacking scandal has surely changed the face of journalism forever leaving common practices of journos in doubt. As always stick with this blog for any developments, as I'm writing this blog the story is no doubt already changing and I'll have missed some new revelation. Such is the nature of news in the new media age.
Until Next Time. Stay Classy Internet.
(and check your phone hasn't been hacked, the police are contacting over 4000 people so it might have been).
Some good links for you on the subject:
Daily Mail Cameron's response
Guardian NotW Closure
Fellow Student blogs. Ewan Kennerell and Daniel Mackrell
Showing posts with label Newspapers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Newspapers. Show all posts
Friday, 8 July 2011
Saturday, 11 December 2010
The Independent - Journalism Now
The Independent was launched in 1986 and is one of the youngest national daily newspapers in the UK. It was first published on 7 October 1986 as a broadsheet by Newspaper Publishing plc and was created by three former journalists of The Daily Telegraph, Andreas Whittam Smith, Stephen Glover and Matthew Symonds.
Its main focus was to challenge The Guardian for centre left readers and The Times as a newspaper of record. It launched with the slogan “It is. Are you?” attracting staff from Murdoch owned broadsheets who preferred not to move to Wapping. It sparked a price war and caused a shake up with its new design style[1].
Today it is struggling to survive in the economic climate and a difficult time in general for newspapers with its ownership having changed hands to a company controlled by Alexander Lebedev and Evgeny Lebedev, the father and son team having previously bought a controlling stake in London’s Evening Standard[1].
The paper’s political stance was intended to reflect the centre of the British political spectrum but is now thought to be tending towards left wing ideals making it The Guardian’s main competitor. On the eve of the most recent general election however it made its stance clear, advising “There is a strong case for progressively minded voters to lend their support to the Liberal Democrats.”[1]
On The Independent website it claims its readers are mostly male with 57%, this is also the same percentage whom the paper believes are solus readers; people who only read The Independent[2]. It places its readers in the ABC1 category which is not surprising considering the news agenda and even the price of the paper. When compared to the Daily Star at about 30p, £1 actually seems like quite a lot to pay for a newspaper.
The audience can also be discerned from the advertising with large adverts for brands such as House of Fraser or Waitrose, the paper is placing itself firmly in the ABC1 bracket. A page advert in colour in The Independent in a specified position is £16,660[3] so companies like Currys must think it worthwhile to advertise in the paper even with its small readership.
The audience profiles also suggest that most of their readers are professionals as 59% are in full time employment with 50% with degree level or higher in their education. A large majority as well are from the London and South East area[2].
The newspaper’s agenda ranges from political prisoners to climate change and often focuses on the stories like this that it sees as more ‘worthy’. You will not find celebrity based gossip in The Independent although you are more likely to find it on the website.
The Independent has also recently launched the ‘I’ newspaper which runs in conjunction with The Independent as its cheaper and more disposable cousin. The editorial is mostly similar and in fact on some days the articles that appear in The Independent find their way into the ‘I’; it just strikes me as odd however that a paper that is struggling to stay afloat has introduced yet another rival, one that is cheaper and more cost effective.
Like all newspapers and especially the ‘qualities’, The Independent’s circulation is dropping rapidly with 183,547 copies in circulation daily. This is down by 10.88% on the previous year. With this in mind it is difficult to see whether the newspaper can survive in the current economic climate or will the populist tabloids soon be the only papers we have.
Sources:
[1] Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Independent
[2] The Independent Website http://www.independentonlinesolutions.com/advertisingGuide/media/indy.pdf
[3] The Independent Website http://www.independentonlinesolutions.com/advertisingGuide/cards.html
Its main focus was to challenge The Guardian for centre left readers and The Times as a newspaper of record. It launched with the slogan “It is. Are you?” attracting staff from Murdoch owned broadsheets who preferred not to move to Wapping. It sparked a price war and caused a shake up with its new design style[1].
Today it is struggling to survive in the economic climate and a difficult time in general for newspapers with its ownership having changed hands to a company controlled by Alexander Lebedev and Evgeny Lebedev, the father and son team having previously bought a controlling stake in London’s Evening Standard[1].
The paper’s political stance was intended to reflect the centre of the British political spectrum but is now thought to be tending towards left wing ideals making it The Guardian’s main competitor. On the eve of the most recent general election however it made its stance clear, advising “There is a strong case for progressively minded voters to lend their support to the Liberal Democrats.”[1]
On The Independent website it claims its readers are mostly male with 57%, this is also the same percentage whom the paper believes are solus readers; people who only read The Independent[2]. It places its readers in the ABC1 category which is not surprising considering the news agenda and even the price of the paper. When compared to the Daily Star at about 30p, £1 actually seems like quite a lot to pay for a newspaper.
The audience can also be discerned from the advertising with large adverts for brands such as House of Fraser or Waitrose, the paper is placing itself firmly in the ABC1 bracket. A page advert in colour in The Independent in a specified position is £16,660[3] so companies like Currys must think it worthwhile to advertise in the paper even with its small readership.
The audience profiles also suggest that most of their readers are professionals as 59% are in full time employment with 50% with degree level or higher in their education. A large majority as well are from the London and South East area[2].
The newspaper’s agenda ranges from political prisoners to climate change and often focuses on the stories like this that it sees as more ‘worthy’. You will not find celebrity based gossip in The Independent although you are more likely to find it on the website.
The Independent has also recently launched the ‘I’ newspaper which runs in conjunction with The Independent as its cheaper and more disposable cousin. The editorial is mostly similar and in fact on some days the articles that appear in The Independent find their way into the ‘I’; it just strikes me as odd however that a paper that is struggling to stay afloat has introduced yet another rival, one that is cheaper and more cost effective.
Like all newspapers and especially the ‘qualities’, The Independent’s circulation is dropping rapidly with 183,547 copies in circulation daily. This is down by 10.88% on the previous year. With this in mind it is difficult to see whether the newspaper can survive in the current economic climate or will the populist tabloids soon be the only papers we have.
Sources:
[1] Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Independent
[2] The Independent Website http://www.independentonlinesolutions.com/advertisingGuide/media/indy.pdf
[3] The Independent Website http://www.independentonlinesolutions.com/advertisingGuide/cards.html
Thursday, 4 November 2010
News Agenda - Peter Cole
During our first News Agenda session we were told that it might be worth our while reading Peter Cole's four part series on the national press that was published in The Guardian.
There were some points made that I found quite interesting. For example, the idea that journalists struggle to talk about 'the life of newspapers' in opposition to 'the death of newspapers', simply because we read too many. The articles themselves are therefore not strictly aimed at journalists, although we can gain much from reading them, but they are for the benefit of 'ordinary readers'. The articles are on the subject of the national press, starting mid-market with the Daily Express and the Daily Mail. It makes quite interesting but also humorous points on the obsession of the Express with Diana and Madeleine McCann. It reasons that the real Express obsession is Diana because they have such exceptional Paris contacts. This means the paper can continuously run headlines such as 'Diana: new sensation' or 'Scandal of Diana cover-up' with very little comment or following up of the stories. "The conspiracy theories build without trace. And nobody really knows why". The Mail is an interesting case study as its views are so strong and these views are intended to reflect the prejudices of their readers, not the contemporary world. The Mail also takes 'proper note of [its] demographics rather than pandering to the advertisers' preoccupation with young consumers'. The reason the Mail is doing so much better than the express comes down to two things: Confidence, the Mail's dominant quality and the fact that it knows its 'middle England' audience.
His next article starts with a bold statement, (and one that fortunately would appeal to the readers of the Guardian, he knows his own demographics), claiming that 'the tabloids are another country to readers of this and other serious newspapers'. He notes that the Red top market is dominated by the Sun on weekdays but by the News of the World on Sundays, the tabloids do still hold such influence even with the decline in circulation (however, the Sun is still the highest selling daily). Journalists on national newspapers - even editors of serious newspapers - can't get enough of the tabloids, the stories are followed up in their own columns with little excuse needed to refer back to them. The golden age of the tabloids was when "society was more stratified, when manual work was dominant, when politicians commanded respect, when education was driving social mobility and when stars were glitzy, (Peter Cole's words not mine). Most tabloids tend to feature stories on infidelity by the famous and not so much or drug addictions of the same. The way they get this information has been called into question however after the News of the World were found to have paid for illegally obtained phone intercepts and the Mirror was found to have phoney photos to back allegations of abuse by British troops. Tabloid journalists are the least trusted of all journalists which Cole finds unfair, "some of the best journalists work for tabloids and the techniques of tabloid journalism are the hardest to acquire". The agenda is what has gone 'awry'. The Sun's views on crime and punishment, Europe, asylum and the nanny state still reflect a strong vein of opinion (when they are present).
Whether you call them 'broadsheets' or use the official Audit Bureau of Circulations term, 'qualities', the more correct term would probably be 'serious'. Although it surprised me to learn that the four 'qualities' - Guardian, Telegraph, Times and Independent - have a combined circulation smaller than the Daily Mail's, it did not surprise me to learn they are punching well above their weight, even if the decisions made by our leaders after reading them, can often be wrong. Cole finds the 'serious sector' the most interesting in recent times due to its compact revolution, its engagement with online publishing, the changes in ownership, management and editors, the growth in the importance of Saturday and the huge investment made in giveaway CDs and DVDs. The article also had some interesting points especially for me, considering my news agenda presentation, on the subject of the Independent. He says the Independent is more like a pressure group than a political party, concentrating on the issues it believes its readers care about, carving a niche for itself on a daily fix of war, climate change, Heathrow protests, Darfur and university clearing.
In Cole's final essay on the press, he enthuses on the subject of the thriving multi section supplement paper. Although they are more expensive and often have a lot of waffle in their different sections, we as consumers actually purchase more Sunday newspapers than weekday newspapers. Market research suggests that readers prefer a more manageable product whilst the market demonstrates the complete opposite. Sunday papers have become 'embedded in our culture' even though Sundays have changed completely in society. The serious Sundays have not suffered the drop in circulation of the tabloids and so they are in reasonable health.
Long may this continue and we'll hope that 'the death of the newspaper' is a little over zealous. Perhaps it is 'too soon for obits'.
There were some points made that I found quite interesting. For example, the idea that journalists struggle to talk about 'the life of newspapers' in opposition to 'the death of newspapers', simply because we read too many. The articles themselves are therefore not strictly aimed at journalists, although we can gain much from reading them, but they are for the benefit of 'ordinary readers'. The articles are on the subject of the national press, starting mid-market with the Daily Express and the Daily Mail. It makes quite interesting but also humorous points on the obsession of the Express with Diana and Madeleine McCann. It reasons that the real Express obsession is Diana because they have such exceptional Paris contacts. This means the paper can continuously run headlines such as 'Diana: new sensation' or 'Scandal of Diana cover-up' with very little comment or following up of the stories. "The conspiracy theories build without trace. And nobody really knows why". The Mail is an interesting case study as its views are so strong and these views are intended to reflect the prejudices of their readers, not the contemporary world. The Mail also takes 'proper note of [its] demographics rather than pandering to the advertisers' preoccupation with young consumers'. The reason the Mail is doing so much better than the express comes down to two things: Confidence, the Mail's dominant quality and the fact that it knows its 'middle England' audience.
His next article starts with a bold statement, (and one that fortunately would appeal to the readers of the Guardian, he knows his own demographics), claiming that 'the tabloids are another country to readers of this and other serious newspapers'. He notes that the Red top market is dominated by the Sun on weekdays but by the News of the World on Sundays, the tabloids do still hold such influence even with the decline in circulation (however, the Sun is still the highest selling daily). Journalists on national newspapers - even editors of serious newspapers - can't get enough of the tabloids, the stories are followed up in their own columns with little excuse needed to refer back to them. The golden age of the tabloids was when "society was more stratified, when manual work was dominant, when politicians commanded respect, when education was driving social mobility and when stars were glitzy, (Peter Cole's words not mine). Most tabloids tend to feature stories on infidelity by the famous and not so much or drug addictions of the same. The way they get this information has been called into question however after the News of the World were found to have paid for illegally obtained phone intercepts and the Mirror was found to have phoney photos to back allegations of abuse by British troops. Tabloid journalists are the least trusted of all journalists which Cole finds unfair, "some of the best journalists work for tabloids and the techniques of tabloid journalism are the hardest to acquire". The agenda is what has gone 'awry'. The Sun's views on crime and punishment, Europe, asylum and the nanny state still reflect a strong vein of opinion (when they are present).
Whether you call them 'broadsheets' or use the official Audit Bureau of Circulations term, 'qualities', the more correct term would probably be 'serious'. Although it surprised me to learn that the four 'qualities' - Guardian, Telegraph, Times and Independent - have a combined circulation smaller than the Daily Mail's, it did not surprise me to learn they are punching well above their weight, even if the decisions made by our leaders after reading them, can often be wrong. Cole finds the 'serious sector' the most interesting in recent times due to its compact revolution, its engagement with online publishing, the changes in ownership, management and editors, the growth in the importance of Saturday and the huge investment made in giveaway CDs and DVDs. The article also had some interesting points especially for me, considering my news agenda presentation, on the subject of the Independent. He says the Independent is more like a pressure group than a political party, concentrating on the issues it believes its readers care about, carving a niche for itself on a daily fix of war, climate change, Heathrow protests, Darfur and university clearing.
In Cole's final essay on the press, he enthuses on the subject of the thriving multi section supplement paper. Although they are more expensive and often have a lot of waffle in their different sections, we as consumers actually purchase more Sunday newspapers than weekday newspapers. Market research suggests that readers prefer a more manageable product whilst the market demonstrates the complete opposite. Sunday papers have become 'embedded in our culture' even though Sundays have changed completely in society. The serious Sundays have not suffered the drop in circulation of the tabloids and so they are in reasonable health.
Long may this continue and we'll hope that 'the death of the newspaper' is a little over zealous. Perhaps it is 'too soon for obits'.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)