Showing posts with label Libel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Libel. Show all posts

Sunday, 4 November 2012

Defamation, Defamation, Defamation

Hosted by Kirstie Allsop for Channel 4.

Yeah, not really though. Defamation is essentially the legal term for saying bad things about a person. I've rather oversimplified things there but there is a simple bullet point way of defining defamation, and guess what? Here are the bullet points now!!

If what you write or broadcast about someone or a company 'tends to...'
  • Lower them in the estimation of right thinking-people.
  • Causes them to be shunned or avoided.
  • Disparages them in their business, trade or profession.
  • Exposes them to hatred, ridicule or contempt.
There are many different forms of defamation, the most common for journalists being libel. Now do not get the two confused; it's the classic all cod are fish but not all fish are cod, so all libel is defamation but not all defamation is libel, sometimes it can be slander. "Whoa now Graham, you've said another confusing word!" And you'd be right, so now is the time for me to explain these terms. LIBEL in all caps is the written form of defamation. In a really poncey algebra kind of way, Publication + Defamation + Identification = Libel. The more you know. SLANDER on the other hand (also in caps lock) is the spoken form of defamation; it does not need publication to be defamatory or for a person to be taken to court which is the likely outcome of a defamatory statement.

Fortunately there are some defences you can apply when it comes to libel. The best defence you can have for  libel is justification. Justification is simply that your statement is true and you can prove it in court (beyond reasonable doubt etc). The second is fair comment which is technically defined as an honestly held opinion based upon facts or privileged material which is in the public interest (check back to last weeks lecture for the PCC definition of public interest). One of the most solid defences though is absolute privilege which is based on your notes from court reporting mostly; if a judge says something in court and you report it word for word using your shorthand notes and it is FAST, ACCURATE and FAIR as it should always be then you can report any statements made, even if they are highly defamatory. The fun legal loophole here though is that you cannot defame a dead person. I can call any dead person I want anything I want and be completely safe legally. Yay for loopholes!

Defamation cases can often become quite famous as the cases rumble on, for example the Max Mosley case has rumbled on for so long, it's no longer about defamation (because it turned out for the most part to be true), it's now a case of privacy. One of the best (depending on your perspective) cases of defamation in recent times was the Chris Jefferies case. OK so I've definitely mentioned it before but it's because it really has changed things in journalism and in defamation law. Chris Jefferies was the landlord of Joanna Yates who went missing in 2010 later to be found dead which put Jefferies at the centre of a murder enquiry. Nothing wrong with that so far (except the murdering obviously) but what did go wrong next was the fact that newspapers reported Jefferies arrest as if he was definitely the murderer, simply because he looked a little eccentric. It eventually transpired that the murderer was a man named Vincent Tabak and the newspapers did a lot of backtracking, a lot of apologising and a little paying of substantial damages. The reason though that the papers jumping to these conclusions was so bad is that it could have caused serious problems in court. Had Jefferies gone to trial it would have been near impossible to find an unbiased jury who didn't already assume he was the murderer from the character assassination he was facing from the papers.

While that was one case of defamation where an out and out nasty thing was actually said of a person, that isn't the only way to defame a person. You can defame someone simply with the pictures you use in a package with the careless use of a voiceover. So for example in a story about football hooliganism a panning GV of the crowd with a voiceover like, "The (insert your clubs rival team) fans then took to the pitch and wrecked the goals, causing havoc," would be defamatory to the people in that shot as they might be completely innocent bystanders who just happened to be in your GV. The most likely explanation for something like this would be a story has broken and the only footage a reporter has is GVs of the previous weeks game; notice I said explanation rather than excuse as there is no excuse for that kind of mistake, you can and will be sued. The newspaper version of this is juxtaposition libel which can happen when a headline relating to one story saying, I dunno, "serial murderer finally captured," is put slap bang next to a picture from another story, leading the reader to assume the two are connected and therefore it libels the person in the picture. I've been doing a bit of reading and it appears the first case of juxtaposition libel involved a certain Madame Tussaud. Now you wouldn't think waxworks could cause much of a problem but in a blog from an old WINOL-ite you can read all about it

Finally I want to give a brief mention to the Reynolds defence. The points that make it up are as follows, laid down by Lord Nicholls during the Reynolds vs Times Newspaper case:

1. Seriousness of allegation - The more serious the charge, the more the public is misinformed and the individual harmed, if the allegation is not true.
2. Nature of information - The extent to which the subject matter is a matter of public concern.
3. Source of information - Some informants have no direct knowledge of the events. Some have their own axes to grind, or are being paid for their stories.
4. Steps taken to verify the information - It is always important to check whether the information is true.
5. Status of the information - The allegation may have already been the subject of an investigation which commands respect.
6 . The urgency of the matter - Is the news perishable? Courts must take in to account the need of journalists to work and publish quickly.
7. Whether comment was sought from claimant - The person who is defamed may have information others do not possess or have not disclosed. An approach to the claimant is not always necessary.
8. Whether the articles contained the gist of the claimant side of the story - the journalism must be fair.
9. Tone of the article - A newspaper can raise queries or call for an investigation but need not adopt allegations as statements of fact.
10. Circumstances of the publication - Is the story really so urgent that it had to be published when it was.

I've talked a lot about defences but what about the times when you can have no defence? You can have absolutely no defence when you have not checked the facts, when you have not 'referred up', when you have not put yourself in the shoes of the person or company you are writing about, when you have got carried away by a spicy story, when you have not bothered to wait for a lawyers opinion. On WINOL the system works like this; if a news reporter doesn't show the news editor their package before it goes in to the bulletin or includes something the news editor hasn't seen then it is their fault, if the news editor sees it and defamatory material still goes in then it is their fault, if it is a particularly complicated issue then the editor may be called in until eventually it may go all the way to a lecturer who will pass final judgement on the most legally delicate stories. As always though, recognise the risk.

Until Next Time. Stay Classy Internet.

Tuesday, 10 May 2011

Max Mosley is back!! - Privacy Laws

Remember Max Mosley? Of course you do! He was the motor sports boss who the News of the World reported had a sado masochistic orgy with five women. The bit people really get interested in is that the orgy had supposedly Nazi overtones; interesting if you know your history. Although he was paid damages (£60,000 to be exact) he argued that since the details of his private life were now public knowledge this was not enough to restore his reputation. This is quite interesting when you consider libel as to be a libelous statement one of the criteria is that it lowers the persons reputation in the minds of right thinking people (click here for a separate post on libel). The former president of the International Automobile Federation took his case to the Human Rights Court, challenging UK laws which allow publication without giving targets advanced warning. He claimed that since he was not warned about the papers intention to run the story, so he could not apply for an injunction to prevent the story from being published (Injunctions, here, here and here).

He told the BBC '"This is just about whether the newspapers should have the right to publicise very private aspects of people's lives which there's no public interest in at all - it's just purely for titillation and to sell newspapers."' However the court in Strasbourg begged to differ ruling that "the media was not required to give prior notice" because they are already self regulated and access to civil courts for damages and interim injunctions. Ruling otherwise would also have called into question the defence of public interest as having the press warn the people in question every time a story is about to be published would mean exceptions would have to be made for public interest.
The article is an interesting read and available here on the BBC news website. It will also be interesting to see whether Mosley appeals again and what implication this has on the current injunction news, i.e. supposedly revealing them on Twitter.

Friday, 26 November 2010

Libel - Current Example 2

Whilst sifting through the disjointed ramblings on Twitter I found an absolute gem of a story, reported in today's Guardian, about the PCC (Press Complaints Commission) having to pay out for a libel case after comments made by its chairman Lady Buscombe in relation to the News Of the World's phone hacking allegations.

The case "is believed to be the first successful libel action brought against the press watchdog, whose code of conduct opens with a requirement for the press to 'take care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorted information'".

Just another example of how invaluable Twitter is as a source for news.

To read the full story click on the link below:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/nov/26/pcc-buscombe-apology-phone-hacking

Monday, 15 November 2010

Libel - Current Example

In The Independent today there is a column on media studies within the daily Viewspaper which talks about The Spectator having recently been on the receiving end of some expensive legal cases. The first dates back to 2008 when their site published an article by Stephen Pollard, editor of the Jewish Chronicle, which described a London based Islamist group called IslamExpo as racist, fascist and genocidal. Possibly not the best way to avoid libel action. A couple of months back the magazine had to post an apology but only after incurring substantial losses.

An influential figure of the IslamExpo group, a Palestinian emigre by the name of Mohammed Sawalha has also been settled with by The Spectator after a blog was published on their website which the man considered libellous. The blog, by Melanie Phillips has also incurred costs to the magazine, said to run into hundreds of thousands of pounds. Although these were relatively small publications, they are of course still vulnerable to all sorts of legal action. Middle Eastern politics must be negotiated with care as they present a danger to journalists who do not know their facts. This is also a good example of how dangerous it is sometimes to just put any old thing in your blog. I for one will be more careful from now on, especially as I now know the dangers and can no longer claim ignorance, for all that would have done.

Wednesday, 3 November 2010

Libel - Current example

I was alerted to a current news story on libel through the social networking site Twitter where a user called @bengoldacre said "another reminder for journalists internationally of the need to write about NMT's behaviour (and English libel reform) http://bbc.in/99SfQe.

The story can be viewed via the link above and is an interesting case of where someone is using libel laws to 'suppress legitimate scientific discussion'.

It is also interesting to consider the role of Twitter in all of this. The story would not have come to my attention had it not been Re-Tweeted, (a term used on the site to mean that you have Re-Tweeted someone else's tweet to your own followers, complicated to understand if you are not Twitter literate). Twitter has become a source of news for many people and it is understood that more people go on the web for news these days than pick up a newspaper.
See this brief article for an example: http://technology.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/tech_and_web/article4559162.ece

Tuesday, 5 October 2010

Media Law 2 - Court reporting

The law is an extremely important aspect of society for any Journalist to learn. It has a relevance in all that journalists do because reporting on it is the backbone of our work. It is also extremely important because there are restrictions on us as Journalist sand it is important to know these, you don't really want to be done for contempt of court do you? Well obviously the answer is no, the fine for it can be up to £30,000 or 6 months in Jail. With that in mind, here are my Law notes with some top tips to avoid being done, (now all you need to do is avoid being caught and you're set).

There are three basic legal principles we have to observe as Journalists with the first and in sometime most important being The Presumption of Innocence. Everyone who is being accused of a crime by the police, defended in a court and tried by a jury has to be thought of as innocent until it is proven beyond reasonable doubt that they are guilty. Just because someone has been charged does not make them guilty. This leads on to the concept of prejudice. It is used in law in a similar way to the rest of the world, i.e. that before you have gained any evidence to the contrary, you have pre-judged the person and you have your own preconceived ideas about them. This takes us to contempt of court for which there is no defence. If you in any way shape or form are seen to have prejudiced the jury in some way you WILL be done for contempt of court; it's a strict liability offence and will cause a mistrial. The court is one of the few places where you can't be done for Libel though which will be fully explained in later lectures on the subject of Libel. If you are caught out for libel however, you can occasionally use your 'Qualified Privilege' as a Journalist to grant you exemption from a law in certain cases. These cases are often where the Journalist believes the information they are giving is in the public interest so it is in the public interest to practically destroy someone in the public trust who is lying and doing bad things. If however you are just attacking someone from your privileged position as a Journalist then you lose your qualified privilege because of your own malice. The opposite is the working in the public interest, the public interest is the rock on which we as Journalists stand on.

The second principle is that Justice must be seen to be done. This is where the innocence project that we will tackle in our third year becomes particularly interesting because, using Chris Horrie's example of The Birmingham Six, there is nothing like getting innocent people freed when they have been convicted wrongly. As a journalist you have all these legal rights in the court because you are the eyes and ears of the public. If the Judges had it all their own way, everyone in the country would be at every single trial. Since this isn't practical we have to report the occurrences in the court to make sure justice is done. Finally, the law must be based on evidence, or more specifically admissible evidence. Introducing evidence that is not strictly related to the case or the charge is actually contempt of court. If someone is being charged for a murder, bringing up a bunch of previous theft charges is a serious contempt of court as it would prejudice the jury.

There are two types of court, the criminal court and the civil court. The civil court tends to deal mainly with divorce and libel and so it is not as newsworthy as the criminal court, (except for maybe Celebrity Divorce). As Journalists we tend to stick to the criminal court, again because it is more in the public interest. Barristers are normally found in the Crown court (criminal) with, in the most intelligent way, short wigs. It's the best way to describe them. They have to prove their case beyond reasonable doubt using witnesses. I'm finding it interesting as well even having only been on the course for such a short time that the lectures cross over quite a lot. Proving the case beyond reasonable doubt for example is a form of Descartes Cartesian doubt from the History and Context of Journalism lecture. The idea that you cannot believe a certain thing until you have rationalised it and proved it beyond reasonable doubt is one that resonates across the board to Journalists. There are of course two teams of barristers in the court, prosecution and defence, and for the first day in crown court (cases can go on a year if necessary) it is purely prosecution, the evidence in chief.

It would be wrong to call the Magistrates court a collection on old Tory women who were in some ways busybodies if it wasn't also so right. They have to volunteer for their position and so do not have the same power as a qualified Judge, and with good reason. The most Magistrates can dish out is a £5000 fine or a 6 month jail sentence which is quite enough really. They can also send things to a higher court if necessary because in fairness, all cases have to begin at the Magistrates court, no matter how bad the crime. Indictable crime though, (the kind that gives a sentence of 5 years or longer) cannot be dealt with fully in a Magistrates court using summary justice.

Thanks for reading my Law notes from the second lecture. Hope they were as helpful to you as they are to me.



I'll be updating my blog from now on when I hear of a case that I can apply my new knowledge of the law of Journalists to so look out for new posts as often as I can write them.