Showing posts with label Al Jazeera. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Al Jazeera. Show all posts

Wednesday, 26 October 2011

The 4th and 5th WINOL - It's different from one week to the next

Last weeks WINOL went extremely well in some aspects, in fact some would say the most important aspects as we got the broadcast out on time with no legal issues. We had no guest editor on the fourth WINOL but we were run in a more hands on way than usual by Brian and Angus. Brian took control of the newsroom, spiking any stories that weren't good enough to be broadcast on the BBC and cutting most things to OOV's because they weren't quite good enough but weren't bad enough to be spiked. I had a slightly less stressful job than the week before, back on the straplines writing headlines which is always fun, (favourite was Princess and the PC, wish it was me who'd written that, well played George). We used a different format script this week when it came to WINOL time, one more like the standard you'd get on an actual news show. It looked very much like the scripts I saw on my trip to Al Jazeera last year which makes sense really as Angus took control of it and directed from the gallery, showing us production people how it should be done really.

The week didn't begin with WINOL however, on Tuesday we filmed the first WINOL Life of the year. A One Show style programme in which our presenters are joined by a guest, usually related to feature production, and talk to our features team after being shown their efforts. The guest we had was Sally Churchward, a local journalist on the Southern Daily Echo and a features writer primarily. We had so many technical difficulties in the run up to the actual show, the vision mixer was just impossible to get working although eventually one of of tech friends managed to work their magic just in time for us to get a rehearsal in before the actual recorded broadcast. Unfortunately however, one of our questions suggested that music features were Sally's specialty and in Ewan's package about girl gamers he may have suggested girls only want to play games with unicorns and flowers. Sally is also a vocal feminist. This made things a little awkward to say the least. We persevered though and got a decent broadcast out and with the sound issues we had to deal with, Justina did amazingly to make it sound as good as it did in post production.

Sportsweek went as well as it always does. It's such a fun and easy thing to film and it's great experience for people who want to direct on the Wednesday so they can do it without the pressure of being live. It also gave a George a chance to do what he loves, speaking terrible French phrases to Julie.

When we finally made it to WINOL on the Wednesday we were feeling pretty confident. We'd had a few decent weeks and the production schedule that Dom put together a few weeks back had been great for us on production and I think helps the rest of the team to keep on track as well. I wanted to be on vision mixer again as for some reason, even though it can be stressful trying to set up green screens and making sure the camera changes at the right moments on handover and there are no black holes between VTs. I also took charge of the hard drive for another week on which we collect the headlines and the packages for the bulletin. I personally find that job really stressful but I had all the headlines ready in time to record them and I had the packages ready long before rehearsals started so I should really calm down. The stories themselves weren't particularly strong. Technically our news team is getting better week by week and we've ironed out a lot of issues that we encountered in the early editions. We're still pretty new though and that side of things will keep improving. The stories themselves however are different. We need to all be thinking about stories, reading local papers and asking questions, listening to local people and going to meetings in the hope of securing a story.

All in a all a good couple of weeks on WINOL. I'm going to add a bit more to this blog during the week as I misplaced my debrief notes. Once they're found I'll mention a bit more constructive criticism.

Wednesday, 29 June 2011

Johann Hari and the misleading quotes

Well Johann Hari is in a bit of trouble at the moment and I can't be the only one who's a little confused as to why it's created as much fuss as it has. From what I can tell and from what some journalists have been quick to say is that Hari has lifted quotes from other peoples interviews with his own subjects and in some cases books. The excuse Hari has given is as follows in a quote he didn't say to me, but wrote on his blog.

"When I’ve interviewed a writer, it’s quite common that they will express an idea or sentiment to me that they have expressed before in their writing – and, almost always, they’ve said it more clearly in writing than in speech. (I know I write much more clearly than I speak – whenever I read a transcript of what I’ve said, or it always seems less clear and more clotted. I think we’ve all had that sensation in one form or another).

"So occasionally, at the point in the interview where the subject has expressed an idea, I’ve quoted the idea as they expressed it in writing, rather than how they expressed it in speech."

All seems fair enough I guess, it's not straightforward plagiarism at least but the main gripe many have with Hari's excuse is that whilst this would be bad form for Hari but not unforgivable, he has on some occasions passed off a quote that his subject said in another interview as something said to him at the time. With a delicious irony I am now going to copy and paste one such example straight from the Telegraph Blog of Toby Young (which can be viewed here).

'Take this passage from his interview with [Tony] Negri:

Negri recently described the Soviet Union as “a society criss-crossed with extremely strong instances of creativity and freedom”, which is more than he has ever said for any democracy. He even says that the Soviet Union fell because it was too successful. I point this out, and he replies: “Now you are talking about memory. Who controls memory? Faced with the weight of memory, one must be unreasonable! Reason amounts to eternal Cartesianism. The most beautiful thing is to think ‘against’, to think ‘new’. Memory prevents revolt, rejection, invention, revolution.”

Compare this to what Negri said to [Anne] Dufourmentelle:

Who controls memory? Faced with the weight of memory, one must be unreasonable! Reason amounts to eternal Cartesianism.

It’s the use of a phrase like “I point this out, and he replies” that marks Hari out as a special case. That appears to stray beyond the merely misleading.'

If you know your history it's not the first time Hari has been accused of such misdeeds. You need only to go back to an article in a 2003 issue of Private Eye to find such accusations (archived here).

On Twitter the story exploded with millions of people taking up the hashtag #interviewsbyhari with the most humorous being an example I found on the Al Jazeera blog (read it here) where Twitter user @mattwithers tweeted about an imagined encounter between Hari and ex-England international, John Barnes, it reads "Barnes articulated his footballing philosophy. 'You've got to hold and give,' he said, 'but do it at the right time'. #interviewsbyhari." The line of course coming from the infamous rap in England's 1990 World Cup song World In Motion by New Order (if you don't know it, give it a listen here).

Give the man his due though, he has responded in a thoroughly honest way and it would be wrong of me not to include his views, readable on his blog here.

Articles are being written and updated on the subject almost continuously at the moment so if you want the latest on the subject your best bet is to follow any hashtags on Twitter for articles from a whole range of different perspectives and keep an eye on Hari's blog.

Until Next Time. Stay Classy Internet.

Wednesday, 1 June 2011

Day Trip!!! - To London's Al Jazeera Studios

Well first of all this blog needs to start with a thank you to anyone and everyone who has ever read this blog as the reason I was able to visit Al Jazeera, was on the basis that my blog had reached a ridiculously high Alexa Ranking for a student blog and there had been a bit of a competition amongst the class to try and a) topple me from the top of the rankings and b) win the competition and claim the glory. If you're unaware of Alexa Rankings it may be worth giving my earlier blogs on SEO a look, here and here.

So the day itself started with an early morning journey with fellow journo George Berridge, who was so close to my ranking in the blog competition it almost didn't matter that I won (it totally did matter). We felt like we were commuting, I remember turning to George in our fancy shirts and ties and going, "Somehow this feels like we're proper journalists." And in some way we were, commuting to London for our day at a professional television studio, covering the FA Cup final. Even stopping for a coffee because we were too early to head to the studios made me feel like I was a working journalist. It's the little things I guess. Once we arrived we were still a little bit early, some would call it over eager, I'd say punctual, (and I'd be lying). We waited outside for a little while, wondering at the building when up pulls the shiniest black generic luxury vehicle you have ever seen. It actually seemed to glide. Who should step out of it then but our University lecturer and star of Al Jazeera's English speaking sports coverage but Angus Scott. Suffice to say we were pretty impressed but it only got better from there.

We wander over to the entrance, looking like the lost teenagers we are, walk up to the desk and in our manliest tones pronounce, "We're here to see Angus Scott", (autographs are signed, ladies swoon, lives are made). Unfortunately the man on the desk rather scuppers this by asking us questions, "Who are you here to see again?" "Erm Angus Scott" I squeak. "Al Jazeera" George adds helpfully, we may never have got any further if it wasn't for that. The security man says "OK." Takes our names and tells us to wait for someone to come and collect us, (there's a brief issue where George has the name tag Jorge - "Oh... sorry, I'm Spanish." Fair enough I thought. Jorge is much cooler anyway.) Soon a lovely lady comes downstairs and takes us, two rabbits caught in the headlights, up to the Al Jazeera offices. We could not be more nervous at this point and it's probably due to the nice words of this lady that I didn't break down and cry at some point (probably somewhere between the tour, and being smiled at by one of the star guests). We arrive in the office, wide eyed at just the idea of being in the building. Angus welcomes us and introduces us to the editor who is very accommodating, considering he's about to put out the coverage of the biggest game in English domestic cup football, but I guess you learn to deal with the pressure.

Midway through our tour Angus vaguely points in the direction of the guests green room saying, "Well today we've got Terry in and also Robbie and Tim." This is how nonchalant you get with experience in the business; he's talking about Ex-England and Spurs manager Terry Venables, Ex-Spurs player Tim Sherwood and Liverpool legend Robbie Fowler. My mind was blown even more when I sneaked a look in and Terry Venables smiled and waved at me (probably more so because I'm a Spurs fan). So what we did next was sit, in shock and awe, reading through the script for that afternoon. As we tried to figure out the more complex elements of it we decided to go on a little walk of our own, hoping we'd somehow be able to get the courage to say hello to the guests or walk into the studio. We realised we wouldn't be able to do this when we bumped into Terry Venables leaving the make-up room who said, "Alright lads!" The shock of being called a lad by Terry Venables nearly killed me. As George will tell you I spent most of the next half an hour reminding him what just happened although he was almost as awestruck as me, and he's not even really into football. True story. Finally though, we built up the courage to enter the studio and by all that is holy it was amazing. No disrespect to the equipment we have (it's the best a student could ask for, industry standard) but the backing of billionaire oil barons helps in areas like this. The set was so professional, the cameras were huge, the lighting expansive, everything was just bigger and that little bit better than anything I'd seen before.

The preparations for the programme were over, suddenly Angus and Co. were on air and we were sitting in on a professional at work, just doing his day job (which happens to be a pretty damn cool one for the record). We were there on the floor for every second of the broadcast and a massive thank you goes out to the floor manager and his crew for accommodating us and even bringing us headsets so we could hear the frantic work in the gallery as VTs were chopped, changed and thrown around to fit in with the chat from Angus and his guests. It was amazing to see and hear the studio at work and really gave me a sense of what working on WINOL this year will be like. Surprisingly it didn't scare me too much, it just made me more excited for what's ahead of me on the course and hopefully I'm up to the challenge.

During the first half of the match, we suddenly realised we were hungry and hadn't eaten all day, we'd actually been surviving on adrenaline more than anything else. We were taken down to the canteen where we suddenly realised that they also film QI and This Morning in the building. Practically buzzing at the very possible idea that Stephen Fry could wander in whilst we sit there chowing down on a baguette. After a sneaky look at a huge studio downstairs with seats for an audience as well, we headed back upstairs to rejoin the action in the studio.

The rest of the day went smoothly as well as we chatted to other staff in their green room, tried not to look too awestruck at the guests and dreaded the inevitable end of the day. The game ended, (Manchester City 1 - 0 Stoke City. If it hadn't been for the visit and I was just watching the game at home, I'd have had a shocker of a day) and we had to head home. Angus walked us to the door and then glided away in his shiny black car of awesomeness as we headed for the train. The noodles at one of the food stands in Waterloo station are godly. End blog.

Until Next Time. Stay Classy Internet.

P.S. One final thank you to my University and Angus for making the whole trip possible, it was, as you might be able to tell, an absolutely amazing day in my eyes. Also a thank you to George for helping me to calm down after a brief encounter with Terry Venables. You can see George's blog here he's overtaken me by some ridiculous amount now due to slacking on my part. I shall return.