Monday, 7 November 2011
Philosophy of Language - My 100th Post
I'm going to throw you in right at the deep end by asking you to think about this statement for a second: 'The present King of France is bald'. May not seem earth shattering on your first look but is the statement true or false? Is it even meaningless? The first thing to consider is that there is no present King of France, making the statement false, but the negation of this statement, 'It is not true that the present King of France is bald' and its logical equivalent 'The present King of France is not bald' are no more true than the original statement, even though that is also false. Some philosophers would suggest this makes the statement meaningless, especially since it fails to refer, even though it seems to mean something we can clearly understand. Confused yet, because by this point in Anthony Kenny's book, my head was spinning. This is without a doubt the hardest philosophy we've had to do so far but it's also one of the most important. The logic that you need to solve problems like this was what gave us the ability to programme today's computers. Whenever your computer crashes, you have to ctrl+alt+delete, you get the spinning wheel of death or the computer just gives up on you, it probably means you asked to do something that it couldn't process logically.
I really enjoyed the seminar this week though as the discussion we had really helped me gain an understanding of the subject. The lecture and the reading only succeeded in confusing me but the examples we used in the seminar, whilst still confusing, definitely helped me. I felt that the most interesting thing whilst looking at the philosophy of language was its influence on the computer world. To think that if we had stuck with the Aristotelian logic of, 'All men are mortal, Aristotle is mortal therefore Aristotle is a man' you wouldn't be reading this blog, and arguably you'd be better off. It helped me understand the sense and reference mode of logic that can make even nonsense statements have sense... yeah exactly, that shouldn't work. The phrase, "The morning star is the same as the evening star" is stupid when viewed logically because the morning star and the evening star are both Venus, however you can understand it. You take the sign and the word and come up with the sense with a reference which is the connection you make in your mind. In works of fiction we force a reference onto things that can have no reference to make them understandable. The meaning of a sentence arises from its structure, the predicate (or an object) gives the subject meaning and then we are able to understand it.
To deal with this sort of logic and the philosophy of language, you can't become hung up on the nominal meaning of words like a school teacher would. You need to be thinking about it with cold hard logic of a computer. The phrase "There is nobody on the road" seems simple enough, but it could mean a whole host of things to a computer, it is not logical enough. If there's nobody on the road does that mean there's somebody? Is it just this road or all roads? This can only work if you say "For all possible roads, on this one there is a man. False." Computers work in true or false, in binary in fact. Phrases like "you're evil" have absolutely no meaning to a computer, first you would have to define what evil is. You need to have the three elements of language (words, grammar and syntax) for a sentence to make any sense at all. The main philosophers of language, Frege, Wittgenstein and Russell all see music as the perfect language because it is logical and has grammar and syntax.
As a final point, a statement becomes truer with the more sources of verification there are so if, as in the seminar, you decide that all people who wear blue shirts are evil (I was wearing a blue shirt, read what you will into that) the statement would need to define what evil was, but if you could do that then you would only need to find more examples of where someone in a blue shirt was evil to make your statement truer. It was AJ Ayres who said "The truth of the statement is the verification." Probably with the italics.
Until Next Time. Stay Classy Internet.
Friday, 8 July 2011
Goodbye, cruel World
Is the closure of the News of the World honestly addressing the problem? Already shouts have gone up from some media commentators at the cynical way in which the paper has been closed as a scapegoat for other, much more troubling issues. The first of which is Rebekah Brooks (nee Wade) still holds her job as head of News International when the majority of the hacking took place leading some to joke that Murdoch has gotten rid of the wrong red top (make the connections yourself, you're not stupid). I suppose you could be wondering what is so terrible about the hacking, after all, it was only celebrities hacked right? Sienna Miller won compensation, Andy Gray was hacked as was Hugh Grant (more on him later) and OK the odd politician like John Prescott but what's the big deal. Well I'll tell you. It wasn't just celebrities, in the last week alone we have discovered that the Private Investigators seemingly hired by the NotW hacked the then missing Milly Dowler's phone, the parents of one of the victims of the Soham murders, the families of those killed in the 7/7 bombings and families of soldiers killed on duty in Iraq and Afghanistan. Now this may seem bad enough or it may seem absolutely acceptable depending on your point of view but where they unequivocally crossed the line to me is when they deleted messages on Milly Dowler's phone to make room for more from worried family members, leading her family to believe she was still accessing her phone and therefore still alive which by this time she had sadly met her end.
The actions have been described variously as disgusting, unacceptable and all sorts of other big words which fail to actually bring about any real outcome. It seems that an enquiry will come but how soon and how independent, especially important given that there is a suggestion of corruption in the Metropolitan Police Force. The Police are currently holding their own enquiry and according to Chris Grayling, a judicial enquiry cannot run alongside it. Not knowing the law on this I cannot comment with much authority but I cannot understand why the two can not run concurrently. the suggestion by other panellists was that because the government is 'in bed with Murdoch' as the slightly sordid sounding phrase goes, they want to leave the enquiry as long as possible in the hope that we the public will somehow forget about it. And they are right. We need to act now to get to the bottom of this, this could be one of the most important times for the media, the government and even the public at large. The Press Complaints Commission (PCC) have been criticised, seen as an ineffective way of controlling the press but as their Chairman has pointed out in various interviews and press conferences, you can't regulate a company which consistently lies to you.
In yesterday's Question Time, Hugh Grant, a victim of the hacking himself, went down very well amongst the general public with his views on the NotW, Murdoch and has become a crusader against the hacking which, if nothing else has ensured his movie career will continue for years to come. One thing however was brought to my attention after the programme that, as a training journalist bothered me. Grant at one point spoke of a change in the way in which the press are regulated, something which many would agree with but the draconian measures he seemed to suggest the like of which haven't been seen since the 1800s and although he resorted in the end to cheap digs about Grant's tabloid past, Jon Gaunt was right in saying that too much regulation on the press will mean we no longer have a free press. A free press being essential in a true democracy to hold to account politicians, businessmen and the like.
Something that worried me in all the accusations and revelations was the reaction of the other newspapers to the stories. On the day after the biggest revelations that Milly Dowler's phone was hacked and messages were deleted, the reaction was less than some expected. The Daily Mail for example had a small front page article, a page inside and a small piece in the comment section of the paper. You can be sure it was the same across the board. Take what you want from this but it suggests that the hacking practice was not limited to the News of the World. To think however as some do that this makes all journalists scum is to be more foolish and naive than you could imagine. With the closure of the News of the World we lose the biggest selling newspaper in this country and around 200 staff will lose their jobs as the paper closes. Not all of these people would have been involved in the hacking, most will be PR people and journalists who were just going about their own business doing quality journalism on what used to be a quality newspaper.
As a final thought what will happen with Rupert Murdoch's take over of BSkyB. The decision will obviously be postponed but surely recent events will stop the sale which appeared to be taking place despite laws which should prevent any one person owning such a high percentage of the media. Will Rebekah Brooks ever leave? Andy Coulson has today been arrested and how long can Murdoch protect Brooks with the comprehensive investigations and inquiries ahead of us. Her ability to stay on has lead to many speculating on what it she has (from a nuclear bomb to bikini pictures of Murdoch. Obviously a twitter source). What will it mean for journalists in the future? The phone hacking scandal has surely changed the face of journalism forever leaving common practices of journos in doubt. As always stick with this blog for any developments, as I'm writing this blog the story is no doubt already changing and I'll have missed some new revelation. Such is the nature of news in the new media age.
Until Next Time. Stay Classy Internet.
(and check your phone hasn't been hacked, the police are contacting over 4000 people so it might have been).
Some good links for you on the subject:
Daily Mail Cameron's response
Guardian NotW Closure
Fellow Student blogs. Ewan Kennerell and Daniel Mackrell
Thursday, 24 March 2011
Radio Script - Final Bulletin
Hampshire County Council has agreed to change the way social care is paid for in the area because the current system is thought to be unfair.
In a meeting this past week it was agreed that those who need social care will all have their own individualised budget tailored to their needs. The new plan would ensure that people contribute to their own care based on their ability to pay, not the services they choose.
The new policy will mean an average increase of between twenty eight and thirty six pounds per week for those affected. With heavy cuts to the council’s budget this plan would mean less contribution from the council to certain users of social care whilst others who are less able to pay would receive a larger grant.
Winchester's tourist information centre are pleased to have won an award for being the best tourist centre of the year in the south east region.
The centre's team leader, Sarah Harfield talked to us about the award and what they do for tourism and the community.
AUDIO INSERT NAME: TOURISM AWARD
INWORDS: We try and provide
OUTWORDS: from other TIC's
Duration: 0'15"
The centre is also in to the last four in the national finals with the results being announced on April 15th in Birmingham.
The Safer Neighbourhoods Council aims to promote the plight of Winchester's homeless though the nationwide Spare Change for Real Change campaign.
There will be collection boxes placed in the shops and pubs in the town centre.
Winchester's Trinity Centre which aims to give support and care to the homeless and those in need are giving the campaign their full backing.
We talked to Development Manager Sue McKenna who let us know more.
Audio Insert NAME: SPARE CHANGE AUDIO
INWORDS: Instead of just giving
OUTWORDS: difference to homeless people.
Duration: 0'12"
Thank you for listening if you did, and if you didn't, why not?
Until next time. Stay Classy Internet.
EDIT: Oops. Massive video. Well it goes over the borders but as long as we both don't worry about it or look at it for too long I'm sure everything will be fine.
Saturday, 19 March 2011
Radio Script - Social Care (plus audio!!!)
Here it is...
Hampshire County Council has agreed to change the way social care is paid for in the area because the current system is thought to be unfair.
In a meeting this past week it was agreed that those who need social care will all have their own individualised budget tailored to their needs. The new plan would ensure that people contribute to their own care based on their ability to pay, not the services they choose.
The new policy will mean an average increase of between twenty eight and thirty six pounds per week for those affected. With heavy cuts to the council’s budget this plan would mean less contribution from the council to certain users of social care whilst others who are less able to pay would receive a larger grant.
That was that, essentially a post I'd done before but with audio, any comments and constructive criticism would be appreciated. I can only get better with practice.
Until Next Time. Stay Classy Internet.
Saturday, 30 October 2010
Lecture 3 - Pretty much History
Journalism is turning information into money. Classy way to open a lecture but it's true. it began in Holland and England in the 1600s and has evolved into the money making leviathan that you can observe today. But how did we get to the point where journalism was even possible? As early as 6000 BC the first recorded system for writing came into being (Chinese pictographic script) begging the question, what were people doing in the millions of years before this. We then moved in the next thousands of years through the Egyptian Hieroglyphics and Sumerian Cuneform script, both ideas slightly too complicated to become standard. A big jump takes us to Latin from which much of our language is taken today. Looking at the picture below of the Lindisfarne Gospel you can see that some of the characters have survived to modern times.
In the 1440s Guttenberg's printing press was invented. Singularly the 'most important invention in history', says Einstein and he should know. He went on to say that: 'it gives man a kind of immortality'. Whereas before, ideas could be written down and lost just as quickly, the printing press gave you immortality because your ideas could live forever in books. This led us on to the Renaissance (for more depth on the subject of the Renaissance, check out my older blogs) where the ideas that had come from the Greeks could finally be written down, recorded and saved before another Dark Ages.
As far as journalism goes, not much happened for a few hundred years until the pamphleteers of the Civil War. Before that though there was one publication that got particular mention in the lecture for its significance to news. Foxes Book of Martyrs turned the pulpit into news media as it documents the persecution of all the important martyrs in history. This was one of the first uses of the printing press that wasn't The Bible; OK so it involved the Bible but it opened the door for the printing press to be used for other more diverse practices. The restoration of the Stuart monarchy brought us not only Charles II but John Locke's Essay on Human Understanding, one of the most important pieces we have studied so far, (once again check my previous blogs for notes on John Locke). Eventually, this leads to one of the most important events in the history of journalism; the publication of the first daily newspaper, the Daily Courant (picture below). This was the time of the Whigs in Parliament and Daniel Defoe, sometimes thought of as the father of English journalism, was pamphleteering at this time and was often pilloried for it showing the dangers of journalism in these times.
Comment papers such as The Spectator then began to crop up in the Whig Ascendancy, the content was commercial but witty. This was the time of Joseph Addison and the like whose observations are still wholly readable today. The next real innovation in journalism came with Hogarth and his photo journalism. The minute observations that could be seen within his paintings were able to reflect very accurately whole stories that could not be revealed by the actual articles. His most famous work Gin Alley is often referred back to as one of the best examples of photo journalism, even though it is not really a photo.
From this moment on, the aspects of journalism developed until we get to Fleet Street and then modern journalism. It is these early journalists, (Daniel Defoe, Joseph Addison, not forgetting photo journalist Hogarth), that helped pioneer journalism and make it the profession it is today.
Apologies for taking so long on this blog but it made it eventually.
Stay Classy Internet.
Saturday, 9 October 2010
WINOL
The webcast opened in much the same way as any other news broadcast and it was interesting, looking down the side bar on the Winchester Journalism YouTube channel to see that the House style for WINOL had been long established. I also enjoyed how democratic the show was in that everyone seemed to be able to do their bit, if you weren't live on camera you had put together a bulletin, if you weren't doing that you could be on the camera or up in the gallery controlling which shot we see. I for one am looking forward to getting my own chance in the studio somewhere or out in the field reporting. My only taste of that so far at Winchester has been the brief but enjoyable screen test that I and all the other first year students did on our introductory lecture. After so far doing only theory/blogging based subjects which have been interesting and in some cases quite enlightening, it was nice to see the practical side of Journalism again.
It was good to see how far students had managed to come in only a year. For example at the moment, I do not think I would be able to put together a news show just like that but in a year. Who knows. It'll be the news that me and this years students report on and create that the next crop of Journalism students will write about. If I was to give it some criticism however, I might suggest that the sound quality was not perfect, sometimes strap lines disappeared before you had a chance to read them and on a few of the reports, the voice over was less than enthusiastic which seemed odd when this is the practical part of the course and supposedly the thing you are working towards in your first year.
Overall though a very good job for the first broadcast. I'll be looking out for the next one and any changes that are made throughout the year.
